OAR@UM Community:
/library/oar/handle/123456789/5582
2025-12-26T03:40:15ZCutting edge recruitment best practices : a REA study
/library/oar/handle/123456789/141836
Title: Cutting edge recruitment best practices : a REA study
Abstract: From a structural functionalistic perspective, this dissertation sought to understand how
best to align the processes of formal education, and the processes of recruitment, such that both
develop in syntony, rather than in disharmony. Two knowledge synthesis tools were employed.
In the first part (Chapters 1 and 2 specifically, together with their related appendices), a
traditional literature review was undertaken, for the purpose of understanding how modern
economies are trending to begin with, and thus extrapolate the likely economic scenarios of the
future. The evidence relied upon in this review consisted of expert opinion, and up-to-date
statistical information. In the second part (Chapters 3 and 4 specifically, together with their
related appendices), a Rapid Evidence Assessment (REA) of influential academic literature was
undertaken. The REA specifically analysed thirty-one sources, specifically consisting of sixteen
meta-analyses, two systematic reviews, four cross-sectional studies, and nine traditional
literature reviews, that spanned almost half a century of research, from 1973 to 2022 (please note
Appendix 2 specifically). The systematic manner (please note Chapter 3) by which these thirty-one sources were identified and selected, was novel, and the results appear to have been
promising and fruitful. Additionally, apart from the systematic overview of the said academic
literature, this REA made an original discovery concerning the criteria of job performance, with
the systematically collected evidence clearly suggesting that there is a hierarchical order to these
criteria, meaning that some of these criteria consistently yield higher validities than others,
irrespective of the type of predictor or occupational category (please note RQ3’s Executive
Summary). The key factual findings of this dissertation have been listed in Appendices 32 and
33, for the reader’s convenience.
Description: M.A.(Melit.)2025-01-01T00:00:00ZThe challenges of deepfake technology on the decision-making processes within law enforcement : a study within the EU landscape
/library/oar/handle/123456789/141835
Title: The challenges of deepfake technology on the decision-making processes within law enforcement : a study within the EU landscape
Abstract: This study aims to scrutinize the challenges posed by deepfake technology in the
decision-making processes of law enforcement, both locally and across Europe, categorizing them
into three key areas:
Knowledge and Awareness: Assessing law enforcement officers’ familiarity with deepfake
technologies, associated crimes, and the operational challenges encountered.
Evidence Management: Identifying difficulties in detecting deepfake content, preserving its
evidential integrity, and ensuring its admissibility.
Legal and Procedural Challenges: Analyzing legislative frameworks and courtroom
practices regarding deepfake evidence, and current initiatives to mitigate misuse.
A qualitative research approach was employed, utilizing a structured questionnaire
distributed through intermediaries to law enforcement agencies across the EU, supplemented by
secondary data and case studies to enhance validity through triangulation. Twelve officers responded
(4 from Malta and 8 from other EU countries), all with direct or indirect experience of deepfakes in
criminal investigations.
There was a broad consensus among respondents on a significant lack of preparedness
in addressing deepfake threats, both in terms of detection capabilities and evidentiary handling.
Officers reported substantial difficulties in reliably identifying manipulated media, preserving its
chain of custody, and navigating inconsistent legal standards across jurisdictions. Detection
challenges are compounded by rapid advances in synthetic media quality, often outpacing available
forensic tools.
In contrast to findings from EU respondents, studies from the United States and
Australia show a slightly higher level of operational preparedness, often attributed to earlier adoption
of digital forensic techniques and a more rapid development of AI-focused legal scholarship.
However, even in these jurisdictions, significant concerns remain about evidentiary reliability and
procedural fairness when presenting AI-generated content.
Deepfake evidence presents unique admissibility challenges, such as establishing
authenticity, reliability, and the absence of tampering. Courts are struggling to develop consistent
standards, and current digital evidence frameworks often lack explicit provisions for synthetic media.
There is a growing debate over whether new evidentiary rules are needed or if existing frameworks
(such as chain of custody, expert testimony, and metadata analysis) can adapt adequately.
On the ground, officers report that gaps in regulation and procedural clarity lead to
uncertainties in evidence collection and presentation, delaying investigations or causing reliance on
expert witnesses to establish basic authenticity. Prosecutors express concern over juror perceptions
of manipulated media and the risk of undermining trust in legitimate evidence. These issues often
translate into higher costs, longer case preparation times, and difficulties in achieving convictions.
Description: M.A.(Melit.)2025-01-01T00:00:00ZFrom paper to practice : a critical examination of the role local student dissertations have in supporting evidence-based practices in social work
/library/oar/handle/123456789/141767
Title: From paper to practice : a critical examination of the role local student dissertations have in supporting evidence-based practices in social work
Abstract: This study explored the extent local student dissertations can support evidence-based practices
in social work. Dissertations are often an overlooked resource but strategically arranging their
position could transform them into contextualised sources of evidence with the potential of
narrowing the local research-to-practice gap. Two research questions were formulated to define
the scope of the research, one targeting the academic aspect of the dissertations whilst the other
targeted their use in practice. A mixed methods approach was employed for this study. First, a
quantitative, descriptive analysis paved the way by describing the salient trends and
characteristics of all social work dissertations submitted at the University of Malta between
2019 and 2023. Second, eight qualitative semi-structured interviews were carried out with four
senior academics and four social services managerial employees to answer each research
question, respectively. A deductive thematic analysis was employed to structure the findings
obtained from the interviews into six overarching themes. The quantitative findings
demonstrated that social work dissertations were condensed at undergraduate level, adopted a
qualitative strategy and an observational, descriptive design. Social workers were the most
targeted population and governmental intermediary institutions were the most prevalent. Most
samples were gathered from Malta and the top four most researched topics were ‘social work
practice’, ‘violence against women’, ‘disability’, and ‘substance misuse and addictive
behaviours’. The qualitative findings indicated that both academics and managerial employees
lack a thorough conceptualisation of evidence-based practices, the research-to-practice gap
stems from both human and environmental constraints and published studies are extensively
favoured over unpublished ones. The academics demonstrated a clear distinction between the
expectations imposed across the different academic levels whereas an underdeveloped
publication culture within the Department limits the extent dissertations are shared. Managerial
employees are not particularly inclined to refer to undergraduate dissertations because of their
limited practicality. It was determined that although undergraduates make up the biggest
cohorts, the students lack the necessary analytical skills and field experience to produce
dissertations with strong practical implications. Consequently, dissertations are not embedded
in the practice toolkit of most practitioners and are overlooked as possible sources of
contextualised evidence. To improve the quality and practicality of dissertations, the dynamics
surrounding university-agency collaborations are discussed. The concept of research waste is
explored to address the current misuse of local research resources. The study will conclude
with actionable recommendations to enhance the integration of dissertations into practice.
Description: M.A.(Melit.)2025-01-01T00:00:00ZOptimising monetisation through social media platforms : a case study on MaltaDaily
/library/oar/handle/123456789/139952
Title: Optimising monetisation through social media platforms : a case study on MaltaDaily
Abstract: This study investigates the monetisation strategies employed by social media platforms, using MD as a case study. MD has rapidly become a leading digital media outlet in Malta, adapting traditional media approaches to a social media-first environment. Adopting a qualitative methodology, nine semi-structured interviews were conducted with internal stakeholders, clients, and external experts. Thematic analysis revealed six key themes: authenticity and trust, monetisation models, social media-first content strategy, engagement and performance metrics, challenges in a small, saturated market, and innovation and future growth opportunities. Findings show that MD relies heavily on direct advertising but is actively diversifying its revenue streams through events, subscription models, and service-based income. Authenticity, relatable content, and ethical brand partnerships were identified as critical to sustaining engagement and trust. However, Malta’s limited geographic and demographic size presents distinct challenges, requiring continuous innovation and the adoption of data-driven strategies. The research concludes that diversified monetisation, investment in audience analytics, and technological innovation are essential for MD’s long-term sustainability. Additional to these findings, it provides practical recommendations and contributes to the growing academic discourse on social media entrepreneurship in niche markets, highlighting the unique dynamics of operating within smaller economies.
Description: B.Sc. Bus.& IT(Melit.)2025-01-01T00:00:00Z