Event: The Choiceless Choice: Macbeth into Kumonosu-jo
Date: 19 February 2025
Time: 12:15-14:00
Venue: MKS414, Level 4, MAKS Building
Programme:
12:15 The Choiceless Choice: Macbeth into Kumonosu-jo
Speaker:
Faculty of Media & Knowledge Sciences
Hosted by:
Department of Media & Communications
Faculty of Media & Knowledge Sciences
13:00 Q & A session/informal discussion
This Seminar is part of the MAKS Research Seminar Series.
Abstract:
This talk addresses the general critical misconception that Akira Kurosawa’s Kumonosu-jo, a 1957 transcultural film adaptation of William Shakespeare’s Macbeth retitled Throne of Blood, subverts the tragedy’s oxymoronic intermeshing of its metaphysical preoccupation with predestination and self-determination. Hence, for instance, Joan Mellen’s odd claim that this Japanese film version sacrifices the play’s ambivalent interplay of free will and fate because “[a]mbivalence does not suit the Buddhist-Noh vision of the world Kurosawa has chosen for Throne of Blood”. But Kurosawa, it should be stressed, creates an oxymoronic metaphysical vision parallel to Shakespeare’s by filtering his transmutation of Macbeth through mugen or phantasmal Noh, a subgenre of Noh theatre developed from what Kunio Komparu describes as the latter’s predilection for “[t]he fusion of opposing concepts”. As Keiko I. McDonald astutely observes, in fact, Kurosawa pivots Kumonosu-jo on mugen Noh’s “meeting of two ‘realities’ […] a blend of natural and supernatural planes of existence”. It is indeed this blending blurring any clear-cut distinctions between predestined and premeditated human action that constitutes the cinematic backbone of Kurosawa’s revisioning of Macbeth’s existential predicament, that of having been fated to fall freely. What G. Wilson Knight claims about Macbeth, that “’Nothing is but what is not’: that is the text of the play” is equally applicable to Kurosawa’s film version. But this statement can be viewed in truer perspective if we consider Washizu’s (Macbeth’s) and Miki’s (Banquo’s) forest encounter with the mugen Noh hag who replaces Shakespeare’s three Weird Sisters.
An excerpt from the film in discussion will be shown before the talk.
Speaker's Profile:
Prof. Saviour Catania obtained his Ph.D. in English Literature from the University of Malta with a thesis entitled A Thematic-Semiotic Comparison of Five Wuthering Heights Film Adaptations. His main areas of research are Film Appropriations and Film Theory with a special focus on foreign film versions of English literary works.
His most recent publications include Truth Beauty as Waking Dream: Hitchcock's Vertigo and the Mystic Oxymoron of Keats' Poetry (Literature/Film Quarterly 40.1, 2016); Ferrying Nothingness: The Charon Motif in Murnau's Nosferatu and Dreyer's Vampyr (Melita Classica 3, 2016); The Undying Light: Yoshida, Bataille and the Ambivalent Spectrality of Brontë's Wuthering Heights published in The Brontë Sisters in Other Wor(l)ds (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014); Signifying Nothing: Bresson's Lancelot du Lac and the Arthurian Paradoxism of Tennyson's Idylls (Merope: 23. 59/60, 2014). He has also published articles in Brontë Studies, Entertext, Literature/Film Quarterly, Merope and Studia Filmoznawcze and contributed book chapters to the anthologies Adapting Poe (Palgrave Macmillan, 2012), Shared Waters (co-authored/Rodopi, 2009) and World-Wide Shakespeares (Routledge, 2005). He is currently working on transcultural appropriations of Wuthering Heights on film, including El Sheikh's Al Gharib, Kardar's Dil Diya Dard Liya, Fazil's Dehleez, and Siguion-Reyna's Hihintayin Kita Sa Langit.
He was the lecturer to introduce Film Studies at the University of Malta. The film units he introduced include not only Development of Film Language and Classical and Contemporary Film Theory (within the Faculty of Media and Knowledge Sciences) but also Medieval Literature into Film, Shakespearean Film, and Modern and Post-Modern Novel into Film (within the Department of English, Faculty of Arts). He is also a principal lecturer within the Interdepartmental Masters Programme in Literary Tradition and Popular Culture and the highly innovative Masters Programme in Film Studies developed by Prof. Gloria Lauri Lucente. Within these programmes he lectures together with Prof. Lauri Lucente on Film Technology and the Literary Canon and Film Adaptation, the Literary Tradition and Other Arts.
